Quick Answer: Why Should Antigone Not Be Punished?

What is Creon’s law?

The first is the natural law that a corpse must be buried with respect and the person should be mourned by his or her loved ones.

The second is the martial law decreed by Creon, summarized in these lines.

Antigone is going to put natural law above Creon’s law, and for that, she will pay with her life..

What is haemon’s main argument?

The Oedipus Trilogy Creon’s son, Haemon, reasons with his father to change his mind and free Antigone in order to avoid offending those citizens who side with her. … Haemon’s argument could come from any close advisor, and reason demands that Creon listen and weigh it carefully.

Why is Antigone right?

Antigone was right in defying the King Creon because she had the right to bury her brother and her brother had the right to receive a respectful burial which would honor their family.

Is Polyneices Antigone’s brother?

Polynices was the son of Oedipus and Jocasta in Greek mythology, brother of Eteocles, Antigone and Ismene.

What is Antigone’s tragic flaw?

In Antigone, the central character believes that her flaw is her strength, though it is actually her stubborn loyalty. Antigone’s overarching flaw gives her strength to follow her convictions. She is loyal to her family and her moral convictions.

Why does Antigone kill herself?

Antigone, moved by love for her brother and convinced of the injustice of the command, buried Polyneices secretly. For that she was ordered by Creon to be executed and was immured in a cave, where she hanged herself. Her beloved, Haemon, son of Creon, committed suicide.

What were Antigone’s last words?

Antigone and Creon talk about her impending death, and he tells her, ‘thy life is mine, and that’s enough. ‘ He makes it clear that her life is in his hands. We finally see that she is not as fearless as we first thought.

How does Ismene die?

The 7th-century BC poet Mimnermus accounts that Ismene was murdered by Tydeus, one of the Seven. In this account, Ismene and her lover Theoclymenus met outside of the city during the siege. Tydeus had been told their whereabouts by Athena, and apprehended Ismene while Theoclymenus escaped.

How did Creon find out what Antigone did?

Creon learns from a sentry that someone has buried Polyneices. Creon demands that the sentry discover who did it. He threatens the sentry with death if he can’t figure it out. The sentry brings Antigone in and reports that she was the one who buried Polyneices.

Did Antigone deserve to die?

Antigone rejects her, but she does not deserve to die with her. Ismene swears she will bury Polynices herself then. Antigone calls on Creon to have her arrested, warning him that her disease is catching. Creon relents.

Why was Antigone wrong?

Antigone on the other hand was more right than wrong. Antigone, even though she was violating the human law made by Creon was only following what she thought was right by giving her brother Polynices a proper burial. … Creon believes in obedience to man-made laws. Here he says, “But disobedience is the worst of evils.

What was Creon’s punishment?

Creon’s punishment for killing Antigone is that he loses his family to death. His son, Haemon, stabs himself when he sees that Antigone has hung…

What is the moral of Antigone?

In Antigone, the moral of the story is that of fate. … This moral is incorporated through the actions of both Creon and Antigone. The moral also corresponds with a recurring theme of the abuse of power, something that Creon is more than guilty of.

Is Creon good or bad?

Angry and intent on his will, Creon appears the epitome of the bad, ruthless leader, impervious to the laws of the gods or humanity. As the king of Thebes in Antigone, Creon is a complete autocrat, a leader who identifies the power and dignity of the state entirely with himself.

What is Creon’s tragic flaw?

In “Antigone” the tragic hero is Creon. He suffers because of his flaw: pride. He cannot imagine that anyone else can be right. He is too inflexible and narrow in outlook to heed criticism or admit a mistake.

How does Antigone break the law?

Antigone has violated Creon’s decree because she didn’t want her brother to go to hell if she left Polyneices unburied. Creon says that Antigone is “guilty of double insolence…” Of what two crimes does he think she is guilty? He thinks she is guilty of burying her brother and boasting that she did so.

Was Antigone justified in disobeying the law?

She was brought in by the guards and put before Creon, her life at stake. Antigone was completely justified in her actions – disobeying laws and knowing full-well the consequences. During her heated conversation with Creon, Antigone refers to him as a tyrant.

Is Antigone guilty or innocent?

Chicago, IL – While jurors were split in their decision, judges and audience members in Chicago were unanimous in finding Antigone not guilty of treason, saving the ancient Greek heroine from death by stoning.